The Hewlett-Packard founding family heir leading the opposition to the company's planned merger with Compaq Computer has for the first time sent a letter directly to all HP shareholders, seeking the widest possible support.
Walter Hewlett, son of founder Bill Hewlett, summarized his well-publicized arguments in the letter dated Jan. 15, and responded to criticism that he had offered no alternative to the $24.4 billion deal, as he rallied support for an expected proxy fight.
Roughly a quarter of HP stock is held by retail investors who so far had not received any direct communication from opponents of the deal. HP management plans to hold a vote on the merger in late February or sometime after.
Hewlett says the merger would bloat HP's commodity-like business of PCs and dilute the value of its valuable printing franchise, and the tough integration risks are unacceptable.
Management has responded that the deal would add $5 to $9 per share in value to the combined company, in part by boosting the high-end computer and services franchises.
Management has also said Hewlett, a board member who initially approved the plan but turned against it and took his fight public in November, has not offered an alternative, an issue which he addressed in his letter.
"We want it clearly understood that we are not advocating a 'status quo' strategy for Hewlett-Packard," Hewlett said in the letter. "We advocate building on Hewlett-Packard's strengths and dealing with its problems. Hewlett-Packard needs to focus on what it does well, and to change and grow organically, with targeted tactical acquisitions--a strategy that has proven to be successful in the technology industry."
HP dismissed the letter.
"It is a rehash of the same faulty financial assumptions and analyses," says HP spokeswoman Rebeca Robboy. "It's based on a static view of the industry and the company, and once again fails to offer any alternative to create customer and shareholder value."
Founding family members and trusts with 18 percent of HP stock oppose the deal, and management has pinned its hopes on winning merger approval through support from the institutional stockholders who control a majority of shares.
It has also targeted wider support with an advertising campaign.
HP shares were down 29 cents on Wednesday, to $22.79, and Compaq was up 3 cents, to $11.43, both outperforming other computer maker stocks in afternoon trade on the New York Stock Exchange.
Copyright 2000 Reuters Limited. All rights reserved.
Republication or redistribution of Reuters content, including by framing or similar means, is expressly prohibited without the prior written consent of Reuters.
Reuters shall be not be liable for any errors or delays in the content, or for any actions taken in reliance thereon.