Apple iPhone 4
The Motorola Droid X came close, but even antennagate can't kill the Apple iPhone 4's momentum. For the past three years Apple has made the iPhone the true touch-screen titan and while the competition continues to try to take away its crown, it hasn't happened just yet.
The Droid X made a valiant effort, but it just wasn't meant to be.
Final Score: Apple iPhone 4, 9; Motorola Droid X, 6