The World Series of Linux: Round 1

In Round 1, It's Ubuntu vs. Freespire vs. Xandros

Printer-friendly version Email this CRN article

For untold thousands of developers around the world, it's not a game. For solution providers and their customers, it's not a game.

But the world of desktop Linux has become increasingly competitive, increasingly important to the IT industry, and increasingly available for anyone to try.

So we decided to take a look at some of the best-known Linux desktops available and ask one overriding question: Put to the test of usability in a standard office environment, which is the best Linux desktop in the world?

Welcome to the inaugural edition of CMP Channel's The World Series of Linux.

This is the first time the CMP Channel Test Center has reviewed this number of Linux desktops across a standard hardware testbed, and put them to real-world analysis. We wanted to know whether desktop Linux was, in fact, ready for business and whether it would be worth your while. While the different distributions varied in performance and maturity, our testing has led us to one conclusion.


View the Slide Show

Desktop Linux is now business-ready for small and mid-sized enterprises and workgroups. Driver and application support is significantly advanced from even a year ago. Ease of use has improved and, considering issues with other desktop operating systems in 2007, sometimes even superior. But. . . Yes, there's a "but."

Even though desktop Linux is miles ahead of where it once was, experience varies greatly from distribution to distribution. Distributions vary greatly from hardware configuration to hardware configuration. Even though desktop Linux is free or almost free in most cases, Caveat emptor: Let the buyer beware. It is now a Major League operating system. But even the Major League has teams that range from the Red Sox and Yankees to the Tampa Bay Devil Rays.

You get the picture.

And that leads us to Round 1 of The World Series of Linux.

Ubuntu, Freespire and Xandros square off

Channel Test Center took up the challenge and spent the past few weeks putting together a test bed and collecting various distributions for testing. The test bed is fairly basic and mimics an ordinary office setup: a Systemax PC with an Intel Core 2 Duo processor, 512 Mbytes of memory, and an 80 Gbyte SATA II hard disk drive. HP provides universal drivers for the HP Officejet Pro L7680. The test system was carefully selected to not have any brand-new or exotic components, to give each distribution a fair shot at detecting hardware.

As there are more than 176 Linux distributions, Test Center engineers selected the most popular distributions, Debian-based and RPM-based, for the World Series. The goal is to pit the best Debian-based distro against the best of the RPM-based distro for a final smackdown. The winner of the World Series will be crowned the champion.

Playing in the Debian League was Ubuntu 7.10 Gutsy Gibbon, Freespire (the free version of Linspire), and Xandros Professional Edition. The RPM-based distros, which we'll review in Round 2, include Novell SUSE Linux Enterprise Desktop 10, PC Linux OS, and Fedora 7.

For the initial round of testing, engineers focused on installation and basic office setup. The premise was to imagine an office manager doing basic tasks on the computer -- accessing the Web, opening and creating word processing documents, printing, playing CDs, DVDs, and video clips, installing peripheral devices like a printer, installing security updates, installing other software programs, and attaching external storage devices. The World Series championship round focused on advanced features, such as setting up wireless and mounting networked shares.

A coin toss puts the Debian-league up first.

Ubuntu 7.10, affectionately known throughout its user community as Gutsy Gibbon, kicked off the series. The Ubuntu Live DVD starts up a Gnome desktop with an easily visible link to the installer. The installation was quick and painless, taking only 18 minutes from start to finish. The installer asked about locale/language, how to partition the drives, set a password for security, set the timezone, and identified the servers for updates. Engineers spent another 10 minutes downloading and installing 24 additional updates. (It sounds more difficult than it was.)

In fact, everything about Ubuntu was quick and effortless. Updates were easy. A flashing icon on the top right corner of the screen indicated new updates and all engineers had to do was select which ones to install. Networking was simple, since the installer found and configured the network automatically. Printing was also straightforward. Ubuntu detected the printer as soon as the USB cable was plugged in and configured. The printer install was truly plug-and-play.

Wireshark, the network monitoring tool, was installed using the Add Software option on the menu. Like the updates, it was a painless process. There was no trouble watching a DVD or listening to a CD, either. When the USB drive was plugged in, the drive appeared as a little icon on the desktop automatically.

Canonical has made the effort to make Ubuntu user-friendly, and it showed in this round of testing. All the menu options were easily accessible and organized in a very logical manner. Considering that Linux used to be synonymous with arcane commands and complicated syntax, this was a complete turnaround.


NEXT: Xandros and Freespire

Printer-friendly version Email this CRN article