Downgrade rights allow customers who buy new PCs with Vista Business or Vista Ultimate to revert back to XP Professional. Last week, Los Angeles resident Emma Alvarado filed a complaint in Seattle federal court accusing Microsoft of forcing customers to buy Vista PCs so that it could charge them for XP downgrades.
But Microsoft insists that downgrade rights are part of the Vista EULA and are simply an option it offers customers. "This complaint is mistaken. Microsoft does not charge for downgrades," said Microsoft spokesperson David Bowermaster. "If a customer exercises those rights, Microsoft does not charge or receive any additional royalty."
Microsoft also stands accused of twice extending the OEM deadline for downgrades -- to its current date of July 31 -- in order to continue reaping "tremendous profits" from downgrades. Microsoft also denies these claims. "The allegations about obtaining monopoly power or using it to profit from downgrading to Windows XP make no sense," Bowermaster said.
The irony here is that Microsoft would love nothing better than for talk of downgrade rights to go away. The fact that it hasn't yet speaks to the market's deep-seated loathing of Vista, and negative perceptions that persist in spite of Microsoft's far-reaching and expensive efforts to rehabilitate Vista's image.
With Windows 7's release due sometime later this year, Microsoft has begun drilling home the message that XP is ill-suited to handle the complex security, compliance and productivity needs of today's enterprises, particularly when it comes to mobile computing. The message has also been that migrating to Vista now fixes these potential weaknesses.
Microsoft hasn't made it easy for partners to perform XP downgrades. In June 2007, Microsoft gave its Gold Certified partners the ability to perform Vista downgrades online through an automated process. Prior to that, downgrades were a time-consuming slog that required phone calls to Microsoft and validation of PCs on a one-by-one basis. Currently, non-Gold Certified system builders must also follow this path for downgrades.
The point of the lawsuit, then, appears to be with the charges that OEMs levy for executing the XP downgrades. And according to system builders, the downgrade process is time-consuming enough to warrant a fee.
Customers can perform downgrades on their own, but the process isn't easy, and an original copy of the media with a COA (Certificate Of Authenticity) is required to get the downgrade to work, said Todd Swank, vice president of marketing at system builder Nor-Tech, Burnsville, Minn.
Nor-Tech doesn't charge for performing the downgrade on new PCs it sells, and provides the service as a value-add.
Paul DeGroot, an analyst with Directions On Microsoft, says it appears that OEMs are charging what they feel is appropriate for downgrades, which means it's difficult to see how Microsoft could be vulnerable in this case.
"There's a certain amount of extra current to fight when you depart from the mainstream, and that's basically what these people are paying for," he said.
related stories
Video
trending stories
sponsored resources

OutSystems
Modern Application Development 360

Symantec
Symantec Business Security Learning Center

HP Amplify™ - A Simplified Global Program for the Customer-Driven Digital Age
HP Inc.

Dell Technologies
Dell Technologies Cloud Learning Center

NPD
Industry Trends 360

EPOS
EPOS

Smart 3rd Party
3rd Party Maintenance 360

Products of the Year Showcase

Cysurance
Cyber Insurance 360

Dell Technologies
Dell Technologies Storage Learning Center

BlackBerry
BlackBerry Learning Center

Spectrum Partner Program
Spectrum Partner Program

ADT
Network Security 360

Dell Technologies
Dell Technologies Server Learning Center

WatchGuard
WatchGuard

APC by Schneider Electric
IoT Platforms 360

Tenable
Cyber Risk 360

StorageCraft
Disaster Recovery Learning Center

Wasabi
Wasabi

Webroot
Webroot Learning Center

HubStor
Cloud Backup 360

Carbonite
Cloud Storage 360

Comcast
Comcast Business Learning Center

Trend Micro
Managed Security 360

Dell Technologies
Dell Technologies Hybrid Cloud Learning Center

Veeam
Veeam

Application Integration 360

APC by Schneider Electric
APC LEARNING CENTER
