The framework, detailed in a white paper released in September, defines the two sources of public returns as value to the public that results from improving the government itself, and value that results from delivering specific benefits directly to persons or groups. Conceptual in nature, the framework essentially identifies the public's point of view as the basis for assessing the return for IT investments, rather than technology development and implementation. Public stakeholders include citizens, as well as businesses and community organizations.
"We refer to the [concept] as 'line of sight,'" said Tony Cresswell, deputy director of the Center for Technology in Government during a press and analyst briefing Tuesday. "It's about being able to see from idea through to public value, including the linkages to get there."
In that sense, the framework acts as a valuable tool for assessing IT initiatives that carry benefits not easily translated into a fiscal return; building a public park, for example, won't necessarily pad the budget of a state or city government, but carries value to the community just the same. In terms of IT, a Web portal that provides agency information to citizens may seem limited in its payback or cost savings, but can do wonders for approval ratings and efficiency. So, if a state chief information officer has 20 IT projects on the table, but budget for only five, the framework provides a means of assessing that kind of public value for proper consideration.
Washington is one success story highlighted in the white paper. The state informally used this type of process to green light a digital archiving system for government records, emphasizing not the technology for digitizing documents, but rather the need to preserve and provide access to records of enduring legal and historical significance.
"What we did wasn't about money; we had to go in and explain why this is important and why the public would benefit," says Adam Jansen, digital archivist at the Washington State Digital Archives. "It's about education early on. How do you sell it?"
Similarly for the channel, the framework acts as a sales tool for demonstrating to the government customer potential benefits of an enterprise solution that might not cut costs, but could improve efficiency and satisfaction of constituents.
Acknowledgement of "public value" of IT initiatives by vendors, solution providers and government customers themselves is the first step; next, the Center for Technology in Government and SAP hope government will execute the framework when evaluating possible IT programs and, in turn, drive change in how procurements are structured. The challenge, however, is overcoming the tendency for requests for proposals (RFPs) to not consider any bigger picture -- focusing squarely on cost savings derived by specific IT solutions.
"We lack good standards and practices about how to specify this kind of ROI in the procurements," Cresswell said. "That's the missing piece of the puzzle."
Rand Blazer, SAP's president of public services, agrees.
"There needs to be linkage, because until you can quantify the softer areas [of ROI], you will run into problems with procurement," he says. "Part of the problem is they define these [IT initiatives] as projects rather than transformations."
related stories
Video
trending stories
sponsored resources

Cysurance
Cyber Insurance 360

Tenable
Cyber Risk 360

Dell Technologies
Dell Technologies Cloud Learning Center

EPOS
EPOS

Fujifilm
Fujifilm

Application Integration 360

Mimecast
Mimecast

Hitachi Vantara
Hitachi Vantara

Dell Technologies
Dell Technologies Storage Learning Center

Carbonite
Cloud Storage 360

Webroot
Webroot Learning Center

BlackBerry
BlackBerry Learning Center

NPD
Industry Trends 360

Symantec
Symantec Business Security Learning Center

Channel Chief Showcase

Acer
Remote Workforce 360

Sherweb
Sherweb

APC by Schneider Electric
Digital Services for Edge Learning Center

StorageCraft
Disaster Recovery Learning Center

Vertiv
Edge Computing Learning Center

Wasabi
Wasabi

Dell Technologies
Dell Technologies Hybrid Cloud Learning Center

Cradlepoint
5g for Business 360

Comm100
Collaboration & Communications 360

Veeam
Veeam

Smart 3rd Party
3rd Party Maintenance 360

Sophos
Sophos Cybersecurity Learning Center

Trend Micro
Trend Micro Learning Center

VMware

HubStor
Cloud Backup 360

eSentire
Managed Detection and Response 360

Comcast Business
Comcast Business Learning Center
