"I can't think of a time when they were not disingenuous," said Bender, responding to Intel's decision to abandon the OLPC project after only six months working with the organization "I can't think of a single thing they said they were going to do that they actually did."
Bender said Intel, which is selling its own competing Classmate PC product to developing countries, never followed through on widely publicized promises and written agreements to assist the OLPC on software development and learning tools. "It was a lot of pie crust promises as Mary Poppins would say," said Bender. "Allegedly they were going to bring the great and mighty Intel learning team to help us, but that never happened."
Intel joined the OLPC last July after several years of tense relations with the non profit organization. Bender said that agreement with the OLPC did not end the feud. "They promised to cooperate on software content and technology and none of that cooperation came about," he said.
Intel was slated to unveil an Intel based version of the OLPC at the Consumer Electronics Show next week. Intel, however, scrapped the product, the company said, because OLPC demanded that Intel stop selling the Classmate PC.
Bender said that is not the whole story. "To isolate that piece is to distort the story," he said. "There is a difference between a reference design and Intel selling the product itself. Intel makes lots of reference designs and lots of companies out there use those reference designs to make products. We didn't ask Intel to stop doing that. But Intel doesn't sell laptops in the U.S. to compete against Dell."
The OLPC charged that even though Intel joined the organization it "continued to disparage" the OLPC product in Uruguay and Peru, in Brazil and Nigeria, which were in the midst of choosing a laptop solution and even in small and remote places like Mongolia. Bender said Intel's disparaging comments about the OLPC were delivered with "real gusto" even after the chip giant joined the organization.
"We got constant complaints from people in the field that they were being bullied by Intel," said Bender. "That was the message we got from anybody and everybody working on these educational problems in the developing world."
As to whether the fundamental difference between the two organizations was Intel's for profit status vs. OLPC's non profit status was a factor, Bender replied: "I think it certainly is a big factor in terms of what motivates people and what motivates people certainly has a big factor on their behavior."
Bender said Intel's behavior was in sharp contrast to other partners, including AMD, Red Hat, Google, eBay and others. "These guys actually get what we are trying to do," he said. "Intel doesn't."
Bender said how Intel handled the split is just another sign of the chip giant's disingenuous dealings with the organization. He said Intel issued a statement to the press "behind the back" of the OLPC, while at the same time working on a joint statement with the organization. "You tell me whether that was underhanded," added Bender.
As to the differences between the Classmate PC and the OLPC, Bender said the Intel system has a "crummy" portable DVD player like display in contrast to the OLPC product. And while the OLPC product can be solar powered or human powered with a crank for children living outside of a power grid, the Classmate PC will ultimately end up consuming more power and costing more, charged Bender.
"Intel makes a a big deal out of all they are doing for learning in the world," said Bender. "Maybe somewhere they are actually doing something. It's hard for me to see it. All I see is Intel marketing the hell out of a pretty mediocre product."
related stories
Video
trending stories
sponsored resources

Veeam
Veeam

Cato Networks
SASE & SD-WAN 360

Channel Chief Showcase

CRN Showcase

APC by Schneider Electric
Digital Services for Edge Learning Center

Acer
Remote Workforce 360

Cradlepoint
5g for Business 360

Smart 3rd Party
3rd Party Maintenance 360

Trend Micro
Trend Micro Learning Center

Partner Program Guide Showcase

Hitachi Vantara
Hitachi Vantara

Sophos
Sophos Cybersecurity Learning Center

Cyber Protection 360

SentinelONE
EndPoint Security 360

Comm100
Collaboration & Communications 360

VMware

HubStor
Cloud Backup 360

Wasabi
Wasabi

Cysurance
Cyber Insurance 360

Dell Technologies
Microsoft HCI Solutions from Dell Technologies Learning Center

Dell Technologies
Dell Technologies Storage Learning Center

Dell Technologies
Dell Technologies Server Learning Center

Dell Technologies
Dell Technologies Cloud Learning Center

Sherweb
Sherweb

Carbonite
Cloud Storage 360

Comcast Business
Comcast Business Learning Center

iboss
Cloud SASE Platform 360

Terranova Security
Cybersecurity 360

CyberPower
CyberPower

N-able
MSP Automation Solutions 360

eSentire
Managed Detection and Response 360

EPOS
EPOS

NPD
Industry Trends 360

Vertiv
Edge Computing Learning Center

Webroot
Webroot Learning Center

Tenable
Cyber Risk 360

BlackBerry
BlackBerry Learning Center

Fujifilm
Fujifilm

Vonage
Vonage
