What The IT Outage (Mini)-Apocalypse Is Really Telling Us About Cybersecurity: Analysis
There’s a definite irony here: At a time when we have every reason to have deep concerns about our cybersecurity posture as a nation, the high-profile outages of the past week all appear to have zero to do with this.
When the FAA’s stunning nationwide ground stop was announced Friday evening, two questions were on many people’s minds: How long will it last? And what caused it?
As it turned out, the answer to the first question about length of the disruption—just a few hours—is pretty helpful in understanding the answer to the second question about the cause.
[Related: FAA Stops Installation of HPE Juniper Routers In Wake Of Ground Stop Investigation]
As cybersecurity luminary Chris Krebs noted this week, if hypothetically it was a cyberattack that caused the FAA outage, it wasn’t a very successful one.
There is no question that this is a time of massive cyber risk in the U.S. and worldwide. Arguably, we are at an all-time high in this regard, given how interconnected our IT systems have become, and how incredibly good AI has gotten at figuring out how to breach them.
By all indications, the arrival of ultra-powerful frontier AI models from Anthropic, OpenAI and open-weight model providers this year has, at least for now, given attackers a massive advantage. For seven months now, I’ve been talking to cybersecurity experts on a pretty much daily basis about this issue, ever since Anthropic disclosed details about the proficiency of Claude Mythos for vulnerability discovery.
So of all people, I can understand why the recent string of widely felt IT outages—not quite an outage apocalypse, but at least a mini-apocalypse—might be assumed to have a connection to cyberattacks.
Obviously, anyone who lost access to Microsoft Outlook last Thursday, watched the FAA halt departures on Friday—and then saw outages at United Airlines, Chase, Apple and others this week—is going to notice a pattern.
The question we need to get crystal clear about, however, is this: What is this a pattern of, exactly?
Many people of varying knowledgeability on the subject have spoken up on social media to propose, “it’s gotta be cyberattacks.”
There’s a definite irony here. At a time when we have every reason to have deep concerns about our cybersecurity posture as a nation, the high-profile outages of the past week all appear to have zero to do with this.
Krebs—whose background included serving as director of the U.S. cybersecurity agency, CISA—has had the best take on this that I’ve seen so far, during an appearance Tuesday on CBS.
Consider how many more systems we’ve now connected at this point, he said, and how rapidly we’re now changing the software they run on. AI tools and agents are being deployed at a breakneck pace.
And yet, much of the underlying infrastructure that businesses are depending upon is what Krebs aptly called “two decades of very fragile—rickety, in some cases—technology.”
In other words, there is a definite pattern to these incidents. It’s just not the one the pundits have fixated upon. There’s no valid reason to believe at this point that it’s a coordinated cyberattack, or even a series of unrelated security compromises.
For instance, while the root cause of the FAA meltdown Friday is still pending, all signs point toward an issue related to a telecom network upgrade, involving a move from 20-year-old Cisco routers to modern HPE Juniper routers.
To be sure, “the upgrade was a good idea,” Jason Rader, global CISO at solution provider powerhouse Insight, told me Wednesday. “But the way that they did it—that’s just a tale as old as time. That happens all the time when [a staff member] doesn’t follow procedures and breaks something.”
Likewise on the Microsoft outage, which the company said stemmed from a prior “network capacity upgrade.” That upgrade had inadvertently introduced a defect that was exposed by a recent network change, causing a failure.
Like with the FAA incident, IT systems were being upgraded, and something went wrong.
I’ll say it again: No evidence has emerged that suggests cyberattacks were responsible for those incidents, or any of the many other high-profile outages that have coincided over the past week.
And yet, as mentioned, cybersecurity risk really, truly is at an unprecedented level right now.
Just ask the residents of South Portland, Maine, where officials said Tuesday that City Hall and the public library would remain closed through at least Thursday after a cyberattack disrupted the city’s computer and phone systems.
Or ask the more than 100 websites—including CNN, Fox News and the BBC, as well as the sites of companies including Zoom and Salesforce—that were reportedly compromised in a software supply chain attack targeting the Optimizely AI service.
The bottom line is this: No, cyberattacks don’t appear to have been behind any of the recent national outages. But yes, the potential for disruptive cyberattacks is real and growing—and in the case of South Portland, Maine, a lot more than just a “potential.”
That’s why I think Krebs is right when he suggests that the best response—to the current situation, or really to any outage going forward—is to “take a beat.”
“Everyone needs to just chill out for a second,” he said.
Only once we do that—and stop letting speculation on social media drive the conversation—will it become possible to make our fragile IT systems more resilient against all types of disruptions.