5 Things To Know About Consumer Reports' 'Not Recommended' Rating For Microsoft Surface

'Not Recommended'

Consumer Reports Thursday said it can no longer recommend Microsoft Surface products as a result of reliability issues. The nonprofit product ratings organization recently surveyed electronics owners and found that Surface devices -- including the Surface Pro and Surface Book -- are prone to more problems over time than competing products. In the following slides, we round up five of the key takeaways from the Consumer Reports analysis of Microsoft Surface devices.

Laptop Issues

Because Microsoft has been producing its own laptops for less than two years, Consumer Reports said this is the first year that there has been enough data to make predictions about the reliability of Surface laptops. The Surface Book was introduced in October 2015, and the Surface Laptop debuted in June of this year. Consumer Reports has pulled recommended status from both laptops -- the 128-GB and 512-GB versions of the Surface Book and the 128-GB and 256-GB versions of the Surface Laptop.

Surface Tablets Are Also Covered

Microsoft's 2-in-1 tablet, the Surface Pro, has been a key product for the company in recent years and has inspired numerous copycats. However, Consumer Reports said the Surface Pro series -- including the most recent model, which debuted in June -- is also included in the findings of poor reliability. Consumer Reports "cannot recommend any other Microsoft laptops or tablets because of poor predicted reliability in comparison to most other brands," the report said.


Consumer Reports said that its survey of users found unusually high rates of "breakage" for Surface devices over time. The survey results suggest that "25 percent of Microsoft laptops and tablets will present their owners with problems by the end of the second year of ownership," the organization said in its report. "For both tablets and laptops, the difference between Microsoft and most other brands is statistically significant, which is why the brand doesn't meet CR's standards for recommended products."

Consumer Reports doesn't mention any other electronics brands by name in its report. But in an interview with Reuters, a Consumer Reports editor said that Apple's devices received the highest reliability ratings in the survey.


The Consumer Reports survey respondents identified device startup as a frequent issue for Surface devices. Unexpected freezing and shutdowns were among the issues mentioned, and touch-screen responsiveness was another issue, according to Consumer Reports. "In a follow-up phone conversation, one of the respondents, a college professor who asked not to be identified, called her Surface device 'quirky' and 'unstable,' with frequent crashes and an unreliable touch screen," the report said.

Microsoft's Response

In a statement e-mailed to CRN, Microsoft said, "While we respect Consumer Reports, we disagree with their findings. Microsoft's real-world return and support rates and customer satisfaction data show we are on par if not better than other devices in the category."

"We stand firmly behind the quality and reliability of the Surface family of devices and continue to make quality our primary focus," the company said.

Consumer Reports noted that the Surface Pro and other Microsoft products have performed well in lab tests. "Based purely on lab performance, the Surface Pro is highly rated when used either as a tablet or with a keyboard attached," Consumer Reports said. "However, predicted reliability is equally important for many shoppers."

Simon Slater, Consumer Reports survey manager, added in the report that "our brand reliability findings have proven to be quite dependable over the years."